LocalPlus
Open Access Plus
Cigna PPO
Dr. Catherine Nicastri, MD
East Setauket, NY
Accepting new patients
28 years of experience
Clinical Overview
Dr. Catherine Nicastri, MD works in East Setauket, NY as
Dr. Nicastri is board certified in
Explains Conditions Well
Patients said this doctor explains conditions well.
Trustworthy
Patients said this doctor is trustworthy.
Low Wait Times
Patients are usually seen in 10 minutes or less.
Friendly Staff
Patients said the staff was friendly.
Easy Scheduling
Patients said scheduling was easy.
Insurance & Payment Information
* Please verify this information when scheduling an appointment.
-
-
Elect Choice (Open Access) EPOChoice Plus POS IIAPCN Choice POS IISelectManaged Choice (Open Access) POSSavings Plus of Metro, NY
-
Fidelis Care
-
BluePPO HSA PPOSimplyBlue/Simply Blue Plus PPO
-
HealthyBlue Advantage
-
Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield PPOEmpire Hospital/Medical (Trad)Empire Hospital
-
MVP Health Plan EPO
-
BlueCard PPO
-
Freedom
Office Locations
-
Stony Brook Internists Ufpc205 N Belle Mead Ave, East Setauket, NY 11733
Patient Experience & Satisfaction
Likelihood to recommend Dr. Nicastri
5.0
Based on 1 Reviews
5 Stars (1)
4 Stars (0)
3 Stars (0)
2 Stars (0)
1 Star (0)
Leave a review
How likely are you to recommend Dr. Nicastri?
Patient Reviews
Aug 11, 2026
it was amazing and the doctors were also. I was not rushed and Dr. McNastri and Dr. Wetekamp were very thorough. Even though I was there for 2 hrs it was worth it. I feel very comfortable with her as my doctor and have confidence in her care of me.
Step 1 of 3
Your review of Dr. Catherine Nicastri, MD
50 characters remaining
1000 characters remaining
Was this a Telehealth appointment?
(This will display with your review)
Your email is used to confirm your review and will NOT appear in the review.
This name will appear with your review. If left blank, we'll use "Anonymous".
RVO Health property, Medical News Today, is owned by RVO Health. Please review our terms of use for more.
Help other patients find the right care by sharing a few more details about your visit.
Last step! Confirm your email.
We've sent an email to
Once you confirm, you can close this window.
Thank you for your review!
Your review has been confirmed and will be published after verification.
Thank you for your review!
We've sent a confirmation email. Your review will appear after you confirm it.
Please allow up to 30 seconds for the email to arrive. Don't see it? Make sure to check your 'spam' and 'updates' folder. Once you've confirmed your review, you can close this window.
Medical Expertise & Background
Specialties*
Internal Medicine
Geriatric Medicine
- *Medical News Today does not verify qualifications for medical specialties. Please verify your provider's specialty and qualifications directly with your provider and applicable medical board.
Common Patient Questions
Dr. Catherine Nicastri, MD accepts new patients on Medical News Today.
Dr. Nicastri accepts Cigna, Aetna, Fidelis Care, Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield, Empire Blue Cross Blue Shield, MVP Health Care, Blue Cross Blue Shield and Oxford Health Plans as well as many others. See all of the insurances Dr. Nicastri accepts here.
Dr. Nicastri's office is located at 205 N Belle Mead Ave East Setauket, NY 11733. Get a map and directions to Dr. Nicastri's office here.
Dr. Nicastri frequently sees patients for
Dr. Nicastri has a star rating of 5.0/5 and has been reviewed 1 times.
Dr. Nicastri is board certified in
Dr. Nicastri has been practicing as a Geriatric Medicine Physician for 28 years.
Education & Credentials
Medical Education
-
State University of New York Downstate Health Sciences University College of Medicine
1998
Board Certifications
- Geriatric Medicine and Internal Medicine
Residency Hospital
- University Hospital SUNY Stony Brook
Claim Your Profile
Are you Dr. Catherine Nicastri, MD?
Affiliated Hospitals & Medical Centers
Know Before You Go
Preventive care: what doctors want you to know
Preventive care can help identify current or future health and medical concerns before they become major.
Featured Stories
Current hypertension guidelines could be overlooking something important: increasing potassium intake while lowering sodium intake may be more effective at reducing blood pressure. Three experts weigh in with their thoughts.
A large review involving almost half a million participants shows why climbing just 6 flights of stairs a day could significantly boost heart health, while reducing risk of death from heart disease and other causes.
Polyethylene, a widely used microplastic, may increase the risk of fatty liver disease, according to a new mouse study. Various steps, such as choosing certain food containers, may help minimize exposure to microplastics.
Explore More Providers
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Intestinal Diverticulitis
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for All Headaches (incl. Migraine)
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Acute Bronchitis
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Acute Lower Respiratory Infection
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Acute Upper Respiratory Infection
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Constipation
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Foot Infection
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Joint Pain
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Leukocytopenia
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Limb Pain
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Pharyngitis
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians for Shortness of Breath
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in New York, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Brooklyn, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Bronx, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Staten Island, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Jamaica, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Flushing, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in New Hyde Park, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Manhasset, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Stony Brook, NY
- Geriatric Medicine Physicians in Yonkers, NY
